Best used cars to buy in 2019

October 17, 2019

When it comes to a pre-owned vehicle, what makes a good car? No, it's not the price or the number of features. A good used car should serve you well over the long term and should not cost a lot to maintain or repair. This means that as a minimum, a good used car should have a solid powertrain. With this in mind, and based on our inside knowledge, we picked several cars. Following the same logic, we recommend looking for a lower-trim model with less expensive electronics and a simple audio system that will have less trouble down the road.

Lexus ES 350

2013 Lexus ES 350
2013 Lexus ES 350, photo credit: Lexus USA.

If Toyota Camry or Avalon is too bland for your taste, check out this beauty. You can buy a 6-year old Lexus ES 350 for about half of the original price or cheaper. There is a good chance that this car will be in good shape and might even have all the service history from the dealer. Yes, some parts could be more expensive, but this car shares many components with Toyota Camry or Avalon. The 3.5L V6 engine (2GR-FE) is one of the best on the market. The ES 350 is fast too; it can sprint to 60 mph in less than 6 seconds. Lexus is one of the most reliable car brands.

Advertisement - Continue reading below

Mazda 3 (2010 and newer)

2018 Mazda 3 5-door
2018 Mazda 3 5-door.

Mazda 3 didn't have a good start. The first generation was prone to rust, front end problems and other issues. However, starting from the 2010 redesign, the quality picked up. The Skyactiv technology introduced in the 2012 Mazda 3 improved fuel economy. The EPA rates the 2018 Mazda 3 sedan with the 2.0L Skyactiv engine and an automatic transmission at 28/37 mpg city/highway. The 2010-plus Mazda 3 offers a solid powertrain and a nicely finished interior. This car is favoured by many driving enthusiasts for its sporty handling. Yes, it's not the quietest vehicle, but it's good where it counts. If you want to avoid expensive problems with the infotainment system, look for a base model. Read our reviews:
2010-2013 Mazda 3
2014-2018 Mazda 3.

Honda Civic

2014 Honda Civic coupe
2014 Honda Civic coupe. Photo: Honda.

Honda started out as a motorcycle manufacturer and succeeded in building many great cars. The Civic is one of them. As the world's largest engine manufacturer, Honda knows a thing or two about what makes a good engine. For years, the Civic has been one of the top choices for a fuel-efficient commuter, thanks in part to a reliable engine. The Civic coupe is a perennial favorite for younger car enthusiasts. We've covered many generations of this great car, and we think that the Civic should be at the top of your list if you are looking for a simple fuel-efficient reliable commuter.
The 2013 Honda Civic with the 1.8L 4 cylinder engine and an automatic transmission is rated at 28/39 mpg (32 mpg combined), Read our reviews:
2012-2015 Honda Civic
2006-2011 Honda Civic

Honda Accord 2008 and newer

2015 Honda Accord
2015 Honda Accord coupe.

The Accord is one of the best family sedans. The Accord coupe is a top pick for a mid-size sporty car. Solid build quality, competent handling and top safety ratings are the key selling points. Honda Accord comes with a 4-cylinder or V6 engine. It has a roomy interior and is good on gas. The 2013-2014 4-cylinder automatic Honda Accord gets 30 mpg combined (26/35 mpg city/highway). Both the 4-cylinder and V6 engines can last long with proper maintenance. This car will not cost a lot to keep it running, which is a big plus. Read our reviews:

Honda Accord 2008-2012
Honda Accord 2013-2017

Toyota Corolla

2012 Toyota Corolla
2012 Toyota Corolla.

People say the Corolla is boring, but this is the kind of boring we like. Do you want your car to start every morning and get you where you need to be with the least hassle? The Corolla is it. It's a little workhorse. In the business world, Toyota is famous for its Toyota Production System. Thanks to this system, Toyota consistently produces good-quality cars. Yes, the Corolla will need some small repairs here and there, but it can last very long with good maintenance.
The 2014 Corolla offers an optional CVT transmission. We prefer models with a conventional 4-speed automatic transmission. Read our reviews:

Toyota Corolla 2009-2013
Toyota Corolla sedan 2014-2018

Toyota Prius, Prius c, Prius v, Lexus CT200h

2012 Toyota Prius
2012 Toyota Prius, Photo credit: Toyota.

It's a hybrid car and yes, the hybrid battery is expensive to replace, but these cars are known to last without too many problems. If you drive a lot, this car should be high on your list. The 2013 Prius is rated 49/46/48 mpg city/highway/combined, how can you beat that? You can drive up to 570 miles (917 km) on one 11.9-gallon (45 liters) tank. The Prius is the size of the Corolla, but roomier inside. There is also a slightly larger Prius v and smaller Prius c which is even more economical. Lexus CT200h is a luxury version of the Prius. All these cars are also reliable. There are a few Youtube videos where Toyota Prius lasted for over 300K and even 400K miles. One of the reasons is that the engine always runs in the optimum rpm range.

Toyota Camry 2010 and newer

2015 Toyota Camry
2015 Toyota Camry.

This car comes "standard" on any list for used car buyers. Toyota Camry is a dependable and comfortable family sedan known for its smooth and quiet ride. The Camry offers plenty of rear-seat and cargo space. The low-maintenance 2.5L 4-cylinder engine is fuel-efficient, yet provides enough power for daily driving. The 3.5L V6 is fast. Both the 2.5L 4-cylinder and 3.5L V6 are very reliable engines. The 2015 4-cylinder Camry with an automatic transmission gets 25/34 mpg and can travel up to 476 miles (766 km) on one tank. Read our reviews:
2007-2011 Toyota Camry
2012-2017 Toyota Camry

Mazda 6 with 4-cylinder non-turbo engine

2016 Mazda 6
2016 Mazda 6. Photo credit: Mazda.

Mazda is known for making sporty cars and Mazda 6 is no exception. The second-generation 2009-2013 Mazda 6 is a large sporty family sedan available with a 4-cylinder or V6 engine. It was produced in association with Ford. For this generation, we recommend the 2.5L 4-cylinder L5 engine; it can last long with regular oil changes.
The third-generation 2014 and newer Mazda 6 is developed solely by Mazda. It offers a fuel-efficient Skyactiv 2.5L inline-4, which is a proven engine with a good track record. The 2014 and newer Mazda 6 is fun to drive and has an upscale interior. The 2014-2016 Mazda 6 with an automatic transmission is rated at 26/37 mpg city/highway, which is very good for a family sedan. You can even buy a Mazda 6 with a manual transmission. Read:
Mazda 6 2009-2013
Mazda 6 2014-2019

Toyota Matrix

2012 Toyota Matrix
2012 Toyota Matrix.

Toyota Matrix is the most practical car you can find. Riding on the Corolla platform, the Matrix offers 49.4 cu. ft of flat cargo space covered with durable plastic. It's also very good on gas. The front passenger seatback folds forward if you need to load a longer item. It's also one of the few small cars suitable for tall drivers, as it has plenty of headroom. The upright driving position makes the entry and exit easy and provides excellent visibility. We recommend the 1.8L engine, as it's known to last. The EPA rates the 2013 1.8L Matrix auto at 26 mpg city and 32 mpg highway. Read our review:
2009-2014 Toyota Matrix

Your choice: Vote for one more car to be included on this list

Vote for your choice.

Ford Taurus 2010 and newer: It's hard to miss this sleek full-size sedan with its solid and quiet ride. The 3.5L V6 is a great engine with one downside: the water pump placement makes it expensive to replace. Should we include it?

Subaru Impreza 2014+: The Subaru FB engine is sensitive to lack of maintenance and overheating, but the Impreza has a standard AWD which is a big plus for a small car. It's good on gas too.

Subaru Legacy 2010+: The Legacy is a mid-size sedan. Although the long-term reliability of the FB amd EZ engines is still a question mark, the Legacy is a great car. It handles well and has a comfortable ride thanks to its low center of gravity and standard AWD.

Infiniti G37/Q50: It's a sporty mid-size sedan with rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive.

Advertisement

It could be expensive to repair as it gets older, but in general, it's a reliable car.

Chevrolet Impala 2010+: It's a big comfortable sedan. The 2014 redesign made it into a head turner. The question we have is, will it be expensive to maintain at higher mileage?

Dodge Challenger: It's a great looking car and an excellent highway cruiser. The V8 is a better choice. Thanks to its iconic image, this car will keep its value for a long time. Of course, you might need to buy another daily driver to keep your Challenger in like-new shape.

Tesla Models S: The model S drives like a dream, but problems down the road might be costly. The main concern is the battery capacity and the condition of the electric drive (motors). On the other hand, there is no engine or oil changes to worry about.