Pros and cons of buying a car with Direct Injection

August 18, 2019

A conventional electronic fuel injection has been used in mass-produced cars since the late 1950's. Until recently, almost all gasoline cars had a multi-point (multi-port) fuel injection, or MPI, and it has been very dependable.

High-pressure fuel injector
High-pressure fuel injector

When it comes to maintenance or repairs, it would be the last thing you'd have to worry about.

Under tighter fuel economy regulations and stricter emission laws, car manufacturers are bringing new technologies. A gasoline direct fuel injection (DI or GDI) is one of them.

A direct injection technology improves the fuel economy by 10-20%, but is it reliable? Does a car with a direct-injection cost more to maintain? What are the pros and cons? First, let's see how it works, compared to a conventional multi-port fuel injection:

How Multi-Port Injection and Direct Injection work

MPI fuel injection
Conventional fuel injection (MPI)

In a gasoline engine with a conventional multi-port (multi-point) fuel injection, an electric fuel pump built inside the gas tank delivers the fuel to the engine fuel rail. The fuel pressure is relatively low: 35-60 psi. The fuel rail distributes the fuel to the injectors. Each cylinder has one fuel injector (green in the image). When commanded by the engine computer, a fuel injector sprays fuel into the intake port where it mixes with air. From there, the air /fuel mixture enters the cylinder through an open intake valve during an intake stroke.

Direct fuel injection (GDI)
Direct fuel injection (GDI)

In a direct injection, a low-pressure fuel pump delivers fuel to the added high-pressure fuel pump first. A high-pressure fuel pump is a mechanical pump driven by one of the engine camshafts. It supplies fuel under very high pressure (up to 3,000 psi) to the fuel rail. A fuel rail distributes the fuel to the high-pressure fuel injectors; one per each cylinder. A high-pressure fuel injector vaporizes fuel directly into the combustion chamber during the compression stroke, when the piston is close to the top, see the image.

Advertisement - Continue reading below

Does a direct-injected engine require more maintenance?

If you check a maintenance schedule for a direct-injected car, you won't likely to find additional service items for a direct injection. For once, a direct injected engine is more sensitive to the gasoline quality, considering the design.

A high pressure fuel pump is driven by a camshaft and this friction point is lubricated by engine oil.

High-pressure fuel pump
Ford EcoBoost high-pressure fuel pump

This means that a low oil level or lack of oil changes can cause problems, but this is true for any engine.

The one problem area specific to direct injection is a carbon buildup on the back of intake valves and on the injectors themselfs. Why does this happen? In any engine, oil vapors from a crankcase ventilation system flow through the intake valves. However, In a conventional MPI fuel injection, injectors spray directly on intake valves, "washing" them off. In a direct-injected engine, fuel is sprayed "under" valves, see the images above. This means that over time, oil vapors from the ventilation system passing through intake valves form carbon deposits on the backside of the valves and on the injectors.

This problem is more noticeable in high-mileage engines, especially if the vehicle is used for frequent short trips. A turbocharger can also make things worse, because at higher mileage, oil leaking from turbocharger seals also ends up in the intake.

This means, that in some direct-injected cars, intakes valves may need cleaning at higher mileage.

High-pressure fuel pump
Audi high pressure fuel pump. Audi calls direct injection Fuel Stratified Injection or FSI/TFSI

If you take your direct-injected vehicle for a tune-up, a dealer or an independent repair shop may offer you a fuel induction service or intake valve cleaning service. Many BMW owners, for example, know about "Walnut blasting" which is a way to clean the intake valves with black walnut shell media ($450-$700). Sometimes intake valves may need to be cleaned manually and this could cost a bit more.

We spoke to an owner of a repair shop specializing in German cars. He recommends cleaning the intake valves every 75,000 miles. According to him, deposits on the intake valves is one of the common problems his shop deals with.

That said, many direct-injected cars don't have any problems. We also found several service bulletins where different auto makers recommend using TOP TIER Detergent Gasoline to avoid problems with a direct injection: Check www.toptiergas.com for the list of fuel suppliers that offer TOP TIER Detergent Gasoline.

There is some progress in DI technology too. Toyota, for example, uses D-4S Fuel Injection in a number in recent Toyota and Lexus vehicles. In the D-4S engine, each cylinder has both, a direct injector and a port injector. Ford also implemented a dual fuel delivery system with two fuel injectors per cylinder in some of the latest models. It's called PFDI- Port Fuel (PFI) and Direct-Injection (DI). This dual-injector technology should eliminate problems with carbon buildup on the intake valves.

Are direct-injected engines reliable?

Mazda Skyactiv direct-injected engine
Mazda Skyactiv direct-injected engine

In general, the more complex the car, the more can go wrong, although some cars have had more problems related to direct injection than others. For example, BMW has had some problems with high pressure pumps and injectors and even issued a recall for a high pressure fuel pump in some models. Volkswagen/Audi had issues in their gasoline 2.0L-turbo FSI (Volkswagen term for direct injection) motor with the high pressure fuel pump follower/cam lobe wearing out. However, for example, Mazda Skyactiv direct-injected gasoline engines generally hold up well with regular oil changes. This means, check the reliability for any car individually.

Where can you check the reliability ratings? First, there is Consumer Reports. We find their ratings to be accurate. To access their ratings online, you would need a paid subscription, but you might be able to find a copy of their printed magazine in a local library. J.D. Power also offers dependability ratings. Check CarComplaints.com to know which cars have more problems.

Pros and cons

To summarize: benefits of a direct injection are better fuel economy, lower emissions and potential for more power. The disadvantages include a more complex design with expensive components, tougher requirements to the gasoline quality and potentially greater repair costs at higher mileage due to problems mentioned above. Often, some of these problems are difficult to diagnose, adding to the repair bill.

What to look for when buying a used car with a direct-injected engine?

When checking a car with direct injection, watch out for the Check Engine light staying on after the engine is started. Avoid a car if there is a gasoline smell noticeable under the hood. A low engine oil level can be an indication of excessive oil consumption. Too high oil level and a gasoline smell may indicate gasoline presence in engine oil, which is also not a good sign. When test-driving the car, watch out for abnormal engine noises, as well as lack of power, misfiring, rough idle or hesitation. Stalling is another sign of engine troubles. A blue or white smoke from the exhaust should tell you to pass on the car. Read more: How to inspect a used car.
We would recommend having the vehicle inspected by a trusted mechanic before signing the contract. If it's a German car, take it to the mechanic specializing in German cars. Avoid the car if it shows signs of lack of maintenance.